Can't take Neurontin (gabapentin) or it didn’t help? You’ve got options. Depending on whether you’re treating neuropathic pain or seizures, different medicines and local treatments can work better for you. Below I’ll lay out the common alternatives, how they differ, and quick practical tips so you can talk with your clinician.
Pregabalin (Lyrica) — Very similar to gabapentin but often works faster and can be easier to dose. Typical start: 75 mg twice daily; some people need 150–300 mg twice daily. Watch for drowsiness, weight gain, and swelling.
Duloxetine (Cymbalta) — An SNRI antidepressant that treats nerve pain (especially diabetic neuropathy) and can help mood. Common dose: 60 mg once daily. Side effects: nausea, dry mouth, sleep changes. Good choice if pain and low mood occur together.
Tricyclic antidepressants (amitriptyline, nortriptyline) — Low doses (10–25 mg at night, up to 75–150 mg) can relieve nerve pain. They work well for many but cause dry mouth, constipation, blurred vision, and can be risky in older adults or with heart problems.
Carbamazepine and oxcarbazepine — Often first-line for trigeminal neuralgia and some neuropathic pains. Carbamazepine may start at 100–200 mg twice daily and is adjusted. It needs blood monitoring and can interact with many drugs.
Antiseizure alternatives for epilepsy — If you used gabapentin for seizures, options include levetiracetam (500 mg twice daily start), lamotrigine (titrated slowly), and valproate (dose varies). Choice depends on seizure type, age, pregnancy plans, and side effects.
Lidocaine 5% patch — Good for localized nerve pain like postherpetic neuralgia. Apply to painful area for up to 12 hours per day. Minor local irritation is the most common problem.
Capsaicin cream or 8% patch — Works by reducing pain signaling in the skin. Over-the-counter creams need regular application; the high‑dose patch is done in clinic and can cause temporary burning during treatment.
Non-drug approaches — Physical therapy, structured exercise, TENS (nerve stimulation), cognitive behavioral therapy, and nerve blocks can help a lot, especially when drugs aren’t tolerated or give partial relief.
How to pick: if pain is widespread or you have mood symptoms, consider duloxetine; if sleepiness is the main trouble, try a TCA at night or a topical option for focal pain; if you have trigeminal neuralgia, carbamazepine often helps first. Always check interactions, kidney or liver issues, and pregnancy plans before switching.
Quick practical tip: don’t stop gabapentin suddenly—many alternatives need overlap or a slow taper. Bring a list of current meds and health issues to your visit so your clinician can pick the safest switch. If side effects appear or pain stays uncontrolled after a few weeks, ask about dose adjustment or a different class of treatment.
As a widely used medication for nerve pain and seizures, Neurontin may not be suitable for everyone. This article explores six effective alternatives available in 2024. Each medication, from Pregabalin to Nortriptyline, offers different benefits and drawbacks. Readers will gain insight into the pros and cons of each option to better manage their health conditions.
Read More
